Recent Discussions

Looking to host a modded server for 10 friends, been out of the game for a while.

Unanswered
Pyrenean Mastiff posted this in #questions
Messages69 messages
Views0 views
Pyrenean MastiffOP
Hey there. Sorry if this is the wrong place to ask, but I'm looking to get a minecraft server set up for this weekend for around 10 friends. The server will host some pretty heavy modpacks, so I'm curious what my best options would be. Ideally I would want an idiot proof provider that is able to set up the modpacks, as I haven't done that in years, but these providers seem to provide lower / cheaper specs than desired. I've been eyeing the "Extreme six" option from servcity at 96 euros, with 6 dedicated 9900x/9950x , but am unsure in their setup, and I would prefer a new york host.
Any tips for where to look or recommended hosts?
Pretty much any established host will use high quality hardware and have their virtualization set up to allocate resources correctly. Bloom, ServCity, Lilypad, Apex, Birdflop, whatever. If they've been around a while and are transparent with their hardware, then you're probably good.

Setting up modpacks for you is a rarer feature. Most of them will give you an admin panel with a file manager. You download the modpack from modrinth or curseforge, upload to your server, and more or less good to go. Some hosts DO provide an automated process for this, but it saves a very small amount of effort.

I run a large, resource intensive modpack on Bloom with 3 cores and 12 GB of ram. I have fewer concurrent players than you do, but have my view distance at max, so ram was critical for that. I pay about $30/mo.

With that in mind, I think you might be going a bit overboard in performance.
@Connecticut Warbler some of their cpus are 15% slower than a i9-9900k for 4-5 usd a gb
yeah, with Apex, you're not really paying for performance, you're paying for really good customer support. or so I've heard. I haven't bought from them before.
Connecticut Warbler
customer support has begun not being very great iirc? and their panel abesloutely sucks
Yeah? Good to know. I'll stop mentioning them, then.
Pyrenean MastiffOP
I appreciate the honesty in regards to performance, I do realize that minecraft runs single thread and all that, but I'm very willing to pay for conveience in this. I will gladly run through some guides and tutorials on how to get stuff set up, but I am mostly concerned about the smoothness of the experience, versus the price
@Pyrenean Mastiff I appreciate the honesty in regards to performance, I do realize that minecraft runs single thread and all that, but I'm very willing to pay for conveience in this. I will gladly run through some guides and tutorials on how to get stuff set up, but I am mostly concerned about the smoothness of the experience, versus the price
Common misconception. Minecraft is NOT singlethreaded. The tick loop runs in a single thread, and a LOT happens in it which causes the tick loop thread to be a common cause of lag, but Minecraft servers use other cores quite actively.
most servers will benefit from having 3-6 cores.
more than that is overkill in most cases.
Pyrenean MastiffOP
Oh interesting, I did not know that
Yeah, I really hate how people have spread "minecraft is singlethreaded!" as a massive reduction of the actual situation. It's close enough to the truth to almost never be corrected, but far enough from the truth to be severely misleading.
Chunk loading and generation, for example, is off the tick loop. So is the networking. Those are both quite heavy processes.
@PM_ME_YOUR_REPO most servers will benefit from having 3-6 cores.
Connecticut Warbler
modded less tbf
only thing in vanilla is a bit of async chunk loading (not generation), chat iirc, and thats about it
networking is only multithreaded on spigot+
@Connecticut Warbler modded less tbf
Fair, but just because mod server software isn't as optimized as paper et al, and because many mods add more shit to tick.
@Connecticut Warbler networking is only multithreaded on spigot+
fair. not in vanilla, you're right.
"optimized" to me in this case is how many threads it can use efficienctly
mods has a single thread combined iirc
depending on the mod i think
but its either main thread or a added thread but yeah
its very not good at a few threads even on paper (unless its for chunk gen**/netty)
@Connecticut Warbler its very not good at a few threads even on paper (unless its for chunk gen**/netty)
Even so, you acknowledge that "minecraft is singlethreaded" is reductive and incorrect.
Pyrenean MastiffOP
Alright, I'll probably try out the 20gb offering from bloom hosts then, thanks for the tip
I don't suppose either of you would be sitting on your favorite guides or tutorials for a server setup?
Loading...